Your job description is (probably) not the problem

Why job descriptions are rarely the real problem 

When job postings fail to convert, people are quick to look at the text. The title needs to be sharper, the intro more powerful, and the bullet points clearer. This is logical, because the job description is visible and tangible. But in practice, little often changes, no matter how much polishing is done. That is because the job description is rarely the real problem. 

The problem lies before the text 

A job advertisement is the endpoint of a process. It is the moment when everything comes together in an external narrative. If the underlying foundation is incorrect, no amount of text can fully resolve the issue. The real cause often lies deeper, namely in the positioning of the role; in the timing of recruitment and in the internal expectations regarding what is achievable. After all, candidates do not just read what is written; they also sense what is missing. 

Candidates read between the lines 

A job vacancy can be strong in content but still yield little response. This often happens when the role is not clearly defined or when the narrative feels inconsistent. Is it clear what someone will be doing? Is it clear why this role is needed now? And does the picture being painted align with the reality of the organization? When this is not the case, doubt arises. And it is precisely this doubt that causes the right candidates to drop out. Even before they apply. 

A text cannot repair the foundation. 

A strong job description can do a lot. It can inspire, clarify, and provide direction. But it cannot save a weak proposition or an unclear role. If the growth prospects are vague, the process is slow, or expectations do not align with the market, candidates sense it immediately. Not because the text is bad, but because the foundation is missing. 

From bandage to amplifier 

Therefore, a good inflow starts not with writing, but with focusing. With an intake where choices are made. Where it becomes clear what is truly important and what is not. Only when that foundation is in place does the job description gain power. Then it becomes not a band-aid for an underlying problem, but an amplifier of a clear and honest story. Do you want to know why your vacancies aren't converting, apart from the text? We would be happy to look with you at where the real bottleneck lies. 

Table of contents

Maybe you also find this interesting?

Recruitment does not have to be an uncertain process.

Schedule an introductory meeting and you will know immediately what is possible for your vacancy. No sales pitch, but concrete advice.

Before you go

No match yet? Start with insight.

Know what your vacancy is worth on the job market. Schedule a free intake and get:
  • A labor market report with current key figures
  • Honest advice from an expert in your field
No obligations. You decide.
Tom is ready for you
The Farrow+Dutch logo in black